Court: Man's legal crusade against TGI Fridays can proceed

AP

Print Article

It's not yet last call for a New Jersey man's lawsuit claiming TGI Fridays broke consumer fraud laws by not publishing drink prices.

A state appeals court ruled Thursday that a lower court erred when it denied class action status to Robert Cameron's lawsuit.

The suit claims Cameron was "shocked" when he dined at a location in Toms River in 2012 and discovered upon paying that his "mass produced" beer cost more than $5 and his soda cost nearly $3.

Cameron claims he wouldn't have ordered the drinks if he had known the prices beforehand, and he alleges the chain purposely hasn't listed them because it has conducted studies showing it can charge more by doing so.

His lawsuit seeks to force TGI Fridays to admit that it violated consumer laws and to include the prices on menus, on behalf of anyone who "received a menu and ordered a beverage from a menu without a price" over a span of several years at two TGI Fridays at the New Jersey shore, according to the court filing.

TGI Fridays, which denies that its policies break the law, says it has added the prices to its menus.

But that isn't enough, according to Sander Friedman, an attorney who argued the case for Cameron.

"The reason you need a class for this kind of thing is they could change back to their old practices and the only thing that could monitor that is Bob Cameron," Friedman said.

Cameron's suit had initially sought monetary damages for all customers who had ordered drinks at restaurants in Toms River and Manahawkin. But that claim was later dropped.

An attorney who argued on behalf of the company didn't return a message Friday seeking comment on the ruling.

The suit is similar to another one filed against the chain several years ago. The state Supreme Court ruled in that case in 2017 that individuals could seek monetary damages, but it denied class action status that could have led to thousands of consolidated claims.

Debra Dugan had alleged consumer fraud laws were violated because prices weren't listed and she was charged one price for a drink at the bar and a higher price at a table.

In Thursday's 2-1 ruling, the state appeals court wrote that while the Supreme Court's 2017 decision in the Dugan case rightly noted that no case law supports requiring a restaurant to list its drink prices, "there is no legal authority that holds to the contrary — that the omission is in fact lawful."

In his dissent, Judge Joseph Yannotti wrote that granting class action status would ignore that many patrons may not actually have suffered financial harm.

"Other patrons may have been return customers, who knew the prices that defendant would charge for beverages," Yannotti wrote. "In addition, other patrons may have had no concern as to the amounts defendant would charge for drinks. Thus, there is a lack of cohesiveness among the putative class members as to whether they were, in fact, harmed by the lack of beverage pricing on the menus."

Print Article

Read More Business

Joe Biden draws line against progressives on health care

AP

July 15, 2019 at 11:23 pm | DES MOINES, Iowa (AP) — Joe Biden is taking an aggressive approach to defending the Affordable Care Act, challenging not just President Donald Trump but also some of his rivals for the Democratic pre...

Comments

Read More

Asian shares mixed in lackluster trading, Nikkei falls 0.6%

AP

July 15, 2019 at 9:00 pm | TOKYO (AP) — Asian shares were little changed and mixed in quiet trading Tuesday amid a lack of fresh market-moving news as investors looked ahead to earnings season. Japan's benchmark Nikkei 225...

Comments

Read More

REC lays off 100 employees in ‘long-term shutdown’

July 15, 2019 at 6:05 pm | Columbia Basin Herald MOSES LAKE — Roughly 100 REC Silicon employees have received layoff notices as a result of the company shutting down production at its facility in Moses Lake. “We worked very hard to avoid this,” sa...

Comments

Read More

AP Top Business News at 11:50 p.m. EDT

AP

July 15, 2019 at 8:50 pm | After years of plenty, auto workers want a bigger slice...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(509) 765-4561
PO Box 910
Moses Lake, WA 98837

©2019 Columbia Basin Herald Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X
X